skip to main content
Accessibility
Check out our Store Events >>
Customer Service
My Account
View Cart (
0
)
1-800-624-7367
Current Catalog
Mobile Menu
Fine Pens
Fountain Pens
Ballpoint Pens
Rollerball Pens
Fahrneys Exclusives
Limited Edition Pens
Calligraphy Pens
Mechanical Pencils
Multi Function Pens
Pen Sets
Children's Pens
Colored Pens & Pencils
Pen Refills and Ink
Fountain Pen Cartridges
Ink Bottles
Fountain Pen Converters
Ballpoint Pen Refills
Rollerball Pen Refills
Pencil Refills
Multi Color Pen Refills
Stylus & Parts
Ink Remover & Cleaner
Ink Wells & Blotters
Desk Accessories
Notepads
Books
Pen Stands
Pen Boxes
Other Desk Accessories
Organizers & Refills
Calligraphy Supplies
Stationery Supplies
Luxury Gifts
Cufflinks
Fine Money Clips
Fine Lighters
Fine Key Rings
Leather Pen Cases
Leather Journals and Notebooks
Leather Wallets
Other Leather Goods
Shop By Brand
Montblanc
Caran d Ache
Cross Pens
Graf von Faber-Castell
Montegrappa
Parker Pen
Pelikan
Waterman Pens
Retro 51
View All
brands
Whats New!
Clearance Fine Pens
Clearance Desk Accessories
SUPER SAVINGS
Fahrney's Pens
Home
Pen Refills and Ink
Pencil Refills
Pen Refills and Ink
Pencil Refills
Clear All
Browse Our
Interactive Catalog
Current Catalog
Customer Service
Catalog Quick Order
Contact Us
FAQs
Privacy Policy
Gift Certificates
Returns Policy
Shipping Information
Help Center
Request a Catalog
Track My Order
"Fahrney’s is THE perfect place to locate unique writing tools. As an ongoing customer, they notify me of specials and new offerings. The website is super easy to navigate, and I enjoy visiting the store in person when in Washington DC." - Verified Buyer, October 2024
Pencil Refills
Order by:
--Sort By--
Popular Items
Name
Price: High to Low
Price: Low to High
Newest
--Show #--
20 Items
40 Items
80 Items
Select One
List
Grid
Yard-O-Led 1.1MM Lead Pencil Refill - 12/Tube
Yard-O Led lead available in a pack of 12- 1.18 mm lead. In three lead hardness- H, HB and ...
In Stock!
$20.25
$20.25
$23.79
Quick Look
Graf von Faber-Castell Magnum Black Perfect Pencil Refill - 3 Pack
Free gift with any Faber-Castell purchase of $100 or more!
Pencil Extenders for Graf von Faber-Castell Magnum Perfect Pencil. 3 - Pack Please note: Erasers are sold ...
In Stock!
$55.00
$55.00
$64.63
Quick Look
Pelikan 9448 0.7mm Pencil Eraser - 5 Pack
Pelikan 0.7mm Pencil Erasers are designed for the Pelikan 200, 250 or 400 style mechanical pencils. Receive 5 erasers per box. Save money today by stocking up on eraser ...
Expected soon Pre-Order Today!
$20.15
$20.15
$23.68
Quick Look
Retro 51 1.15mm Lead Pencil And Black Eraser Refill
Refill your Stealth mechanical pencil and save money when you purchase the Retro 51 1.15mm Lead and Eraser ...
Rating
5.0 out of 5 stars.
In Stock!
$6.00
$6.00
$7.05
Quick Look
Faber-Castell Eraser 10 Pack
Free gift with any Faber-Castell purchase of $100 or more!
This eraser refill is made for the Faber-Castell Ambition, Ondoro & Tamitio pencils. The box includes 10 ...
In Stock!
$20.00
$20.00
$23.50
Quick Look
Graf Von Faber-Castell Magnum Perfect Pencil Refill - 3 Pack
Free gift with any Faber-Castell purchase of $100 or more!
Pencil Extenders for Graf von Faber-Castell Magnum Perfect Pencil. 3 - ...
Expected soon Pre-Order Today!
$55.00
$55.00
$64.63
Quick Look
Super-Polymer 0.9mm Lead Pencil Refills
Super-Polymer 0.9mm lead is formulated specifically for paper surfaces to prevent smearing and fading. Created with polymer resin bonded to carbon and graphite particles, these lead refills never need sharpening, ...
Rating
5.0 out of 5 stars.
In Stock!
$2.25
$2.25
$2.64
Quick Look
Super-Polymer 0.7mm Lead Pencil Refills
High-Polymer 0.7mm lead has been formulated for paper surfaces to prevent smearing and fading. Created with polymer resin bonded to carbon and graphite particles, these lead refills never need sharpening, break ...
Rating
5.0 out of 5 stars.
In Stock!
$2.00
$2.00
$2.35
Quick Look
Super-Polymer 0.5mm Lead Pencil Refills
Super-Polymer 0.5mm lead is specially formulated for paper surfaces. Created with polymer resin bonded to carbon and graphite particles, these lead refills never need sharpening, break less, and last longer. Write ...
In Stock!
$2.00
$2.00
$2.35
Quick Look
Retro 51 1.15mm Lead Pencil And Eraser Refill
Inspire your writing creativity with the Retro 1.15mm Lead And Eraser Refills. They are the essential accessory for the Retro 51 Tornado pencil and will keep you writing when your creativeness strikes. The ...
In Stock!
$6.00
$6.00
$7.05
Quick Look
Graf Von Faber-Castell Magnum Eraser Refill 3/Pack
Free gift with any Faber-Castell purchase of $100 or more!
Graf Von Faber-Castell Erasers for Magnum Perfect Pencil With ...
In Stock!
$22.50
$22.50
$26.44
Quick Look
Caran d'Ache Colored 2mm Lead 4/pack
Caran D'Ache Colored 2MM Lead gives you a beautiful variety of lead colors made with the best materials and the exceptional quality that you have come to expect from Caran D'Ache since 1924. The superior Caran ...
In Stock!
$20.50
$20.50
$24.09
Quick Look
Lamy Z18 Spare Eraser Tip
For all mechanical pencil models of the LAMY AL-star, LAMY vista and LAMY safari ...
In Stock!
$6.00
$6.00
$7.05
Quick Look
Monteverde One Touch Tool Stylus Erasers 5/Pk
Erasers for One Touch Tool Stylus ...
In Stock!
$4.00
$4.00
$4.70
Quick Look
Retro 51 Pink Erasers for Tornado Pencils
Retro 51 Pencil Erasers 6/Pack Features: 6 pack of pink erasers Fits the Tornado Legal pencil Stacked in a convenient tube Ready to use ...
In Stock!
$3.00
$3.00
$3.53
Quick Look
Lamy Z10 Spare Eraser Tips 3 Pack
For all mechanical pencil models of the LAMY 2000, LAMY accent, LAMY agenda, LAMY cp 1, LAMY linea and LAMY st ...
In Stock!
$6.00
$6.00
$7.05
Quick Look
Lamy Z15 Spare Eraser Tips 3 Pack
Lamy Z15 Erasers are suitable for Accent Multi-Function, Tri-Pen and Twin Pen style writing instruments. Each tube comes with three eraser refills. Consider stocking up today to save money on future shipping ...
In Stock!
$6.00
$6.00
$7.05
Quick Look
Faber-Castell Perfect Pencil Lengthener - 5 Pack
Free gift with any Faber-Castell purchase of $100 or more!
Why use a stub? Get more life from each Perfect Pencil with this handy pencil lengthener. 5 Pack Faber-Castell Pencil Lengthener: Made specifically for Faber-Castell Perfect pencil ...
Rating
5.0 out of 5 stars.
In Stock!
$55.00
$55.00
$64.63
Quick Look
Faber-Castell E-Motion 1.4mm Lead Pencil Refill
Free gift with any Faber-Castell purchase of $100 or more!
Fill your E-Motion mechanical pencils with only the best 1.4mm lead refills from Faber-Castell. Made of Super-Polymer lead, these refills break less and leave a lasting impression with each writing experience. The ...
In Stock!
$3.75
$3.75
$4.41
Quick Look
Retro 51 0.9mm Lead Pencil And Eraser Refill
Save money by purchasing Retro 51 0.9mm lead and eraser refills together! 12 pack of lead, 6 pack of ...
$6.00
$6.00
$7.05
Quick Look
Load More
Loading....
Loading....